Safe Home Canning

Red onions I steam canned in red wine vinegar. Delicious on burgers! Recipe from the Ball Complete Book of Home Preserving.

Safe Home Canning

​There are many canning resources available online and in print, however, most of them are unfortunately not safe. Many people do not care about canning safely (i.e., canning rebels) and claim “their kitchen, their rules,” however, I would not want to eat their canning or even their cooking. This blog post is for those who do want to can safely and not worry about making someone sick or even killing them. If you disagree with safe canning practices, please do not comment as I will remove all unsafe canning advice, but I am happy to answer any legitimate questions. Although I have a bachelor’s degree in microbiology, I am not a food scientist, therefore, I encourage anyone learning to read over some of the safe canning resources given below.

Two safe canning resources in North America that test their recipes are Ball (Bernadin in Canada) and NCHFP (National Center for Home Food Preservation, associated with the University of Georgia). Most university extension sites are also safe, but if there is a discrepancy between extension sites or even Ball, go with NCHFP to be safe. I also like a canning blog that only publishes safe recipes from Ball/Bernadin or NCHFP, called Healthy Canning. There are great articles on the Healthy Canning site that explain why certain practices or substitutions to recipes are or are not safe. Also, there is a safe canning group on Facebook, called “Canning” and one of the admins (Ann Crum) also has a YouTube channel called Ann's Mini Homestead, the only one I am aware of that promotes safe canning techniques. In general, avoid any other website, blog, Facebook page, or YouTube channel as it is likely unsafe.

​For printed canning resources in addition to Ball/NCHFP website recipes, there are several Ball books available (safe if from 2005 and later), and you can purchase the NCHFP book from the University of Georgia extension site but all the recipes are also available on their website and can be printed out from there. Most other books available to purchase contain at least some unsafe information. The Ball Blue Book is the basic book that most people start with and includes fermentation recipes for sauerkraut and cucumber pickles in addition to basic water bath and pressure canning recipes. The All New Ball Book includes some updated recipes, including meal-in-a-jar type ones as well as more fermentation recipes. However, that book did receive some criticism for containing a few errors (actually all of them do, most of which have been fixed with subsequent printings) so I looked up the errors on the Healthy Canning website and made the changes directly in the books. The last Ball book is the Ball Complete Book of Home Preserving, which has the most recipes of all the Ball books and is a good addition to your canning library.

Some of the safe canning books from Ball.

Water Bath or Steam Canning

For pickling you have two choices, either canning to preserve it long-term or fridge pickles, which generally last 3-6 months. I follow a Ball or NCHFP recipe if I am planning on canning it to make sure I include the correct amount of acid. If I just want to make a small amount of fridge pickles, usually cucumbers or hot peppers, I will follow either Ball/NCHFP or any recipe I like since it will be stored in the fridge and the total acidity is not as important.

For water bath canning I MUCH prefer a steam canner over the traditional water bath where the water needs to be an inch or two over the top of the jar as it is much faster since you only need to boil 3 quarts of water instead of a whole pot.  The only downside is that it is only recommended for recipes that have 45 minutes or less processing time. This generally isn't a problem for those living under 1000 feet but can come into play if you live at a higher elevation. Two key things with water bath/steam canning are that you need to increase processing times for increasing elevation (see chart) and you need to properly acidify your product if it is not naturally acidic enough to keep the botulism-causing bacteria from growing. Most fruits are acidic enough (exceptions are white peaches, mulberries, and elderberries so these either cannot be canned or are canned with very specific recipes) but tomatoes always need extra acid added to each jar. All tomato varieties are borderline acidic, heirlooms are not more acidic than current varieties, and "low acid" tomatoes have similar levels of acid as any other tomato, they just have more sugar which masks the acidic taste (1).

Pressure Canning

For pressure canning, there are two common stove-top canners (use a canner, not a cooker!): Presto and All-American. If you have a glass top stove check with the manufacturer or manual to make sure it can support the weight of a full canner. To be safe a pressure canner needs to be at least 16-quart capacity (15.5 for the smallest All-American), which is the volume of the pot, not the jars, and you need a minimum of 2-quart jars per canner load (or the equivalent, so 4 pints, 8 half pints, etc., and you can add a quart jar of water for small loads, to take up space). There is currently no electric pressure canner that is considered safe (not even the Instant Pots which have a canning function). Presto has recently released a new electric canner, but it has yet to be tested by an independent source (Oregon State Extension is currently working on testing it) so the best practice is to wait until testing is complete before using them. Additionally, electronic devices can go bad, and it is uncertain if you will be able to have them tested like you can with a dial gauge to make sure they are calibrated properly. Additionally, a stove-top pressure canner with a weight will never give the wrong pressure, so using the weight instead of a gauge is my preferred method. Many people love All-American canners because they are super solid and do not use gaskets, but they are extremely heavy and very expensive. I love my Prestos, I have both sizes and they are much easier to lift, the smaller one heats up and cools down faster, and for the large one, you can double stack pint jars. All-American makes smaller ones but they also make one you can double stack quarts, but it is usually too tall to fit on most stoves if you have a microwave above your stove.

​The key to pressure canning is you need the correct pressure for your elevation. I use the 15-pound weight because I am over 1000 feet so 10 pounds is not enough. You can go by the gauge (for me it is 11 pounds) but then you need it tested yearly to be sure it is still accurate, so it is just easier to use the weight since it is never wrong. If you live under 1000 feet you can use a 10-pound weight, but you need to buy it separately for Presto since they come standard with a 15 lb. Also, if a recipe has both water bath and pressure canning instructions generally the pressure canning instructions just mimic water bath conditions (they do not come up to high enough pressure/temperature to kill botulism spores) so acidification is still necessary. One additional point is that recipes need to be followed exactly, you cannot simply pressure can anything you want to make it safe. Density, pressure, and total canning time (including the vent time and cool-down time) are also important.

A batch of dry beans I pressure canned. Recipe from NCHFP.

References

1. Heflebower, R., & Washburn, C. (2010). The Influence of Different Tomato Varieties on Acidity as It Relates to Home Canning. The Journal of Extension, 48(6), Article 21. https://doi.org/10.34068/joe.48.06.21